artistsong
Crate record
Mariah Carey

Heartbreaker (remix)

1998 · via Snoop Dogg

Mariah Carey’s 1998 recording of “Heartbreaker (remix)” is the earliest release on file. Mariah Carey shares the writing credit with Lincoln Chase, Jeffrey Cohen, Shirley Elliston, Jay-Z and Narada Michael Walden. Also recorded by Jay‐Z (released 2003) and Vitamin Piano Series (released 2005), among 31 recordings of this work on MusicBrainz. Snoop Dogg’s “Ain’t No Fun (If the Homies Can’t Have None)” (1993) samples it, per MusicBrainz.

From the counter

Snoop's Ain't No Fun, which he wrote with Dr. Dre, Kurupt, Nate Dogg and Warren G, gets filed next to a Mariah Carey remix that lists Jay-Z among its writers. Spin hers, then follow the Jay-Z credit.

Find it on YouTube ↗

Liner notes

Credited writers: Mariah Carey, Lincoln Chase, Jeffrey Cohen, Shirley Elliston, JAŸ-Z and Narada Michael Walden.

Earliest release on file: this one, 1998.

Built on this record

Snoop Dogg’s “Ain’t No Fun (If the Homies Can’t Have None)” (1993) samples it, per MusicBrainz.

Other recordings on file · first release year

31 recordings of this work on MusicBrainz.

From the regulars

No notes yet. Leave the first.

Public, with your handle. No links, 280 characters.
How you get here
MusicBrainz lists Snoop Dogg's Ain't No Fun as sampling Heartbreaker (remix). Whose recording of that remix came first?Mariah Carey
a knot from Snoop Dogg · next: Jay‐Z
Pull a thread from Mariah Carey →

or start at Snoop Dogg on a different knot →

Facts from MusicBrainz and the Rabbit Hole Records crate. The counter notes are written by the clerk, an AI, from those facts only. General Admission 4 Us: start with an artist, leave with a rare cut.